Arbitration and Conciliation Act 2021
Published on November, 28 2024

The 1996 Arbitration and Conciliation Act transformed India’s legal framework by establishing a robust mechanism for resolving disputes outside traditional courts. Over the years, amendments in 2015, 2019, and 2021 have further refined the act, addressing evolving challenges in domestic and international arbitration.

The Arbitration and Conciliation (Amendment) Act, 2021 introduces pivotal changes aimed at enhancing efficiency, flexibility, and transparency in arbitration processes. This guide explores these amendments, their impacts, and their challenges for India’s alternative dispute resolution (ADR) landscape.

Major Amends Introduced by the Arbitration and Conciliation Act 2021:

Most Important Amendments Under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act 2021-the 2021 amendment will mostly impact two critical changes, namely automatic stay of arbitral awards and extension of qualifications for arbitrators.

Automatic stay-on awards

The introduction of automatic stay on arbitral awards is one of the most debated issues in the 2021 amendment. Under section 36(3)(b), a court may stay an arbitral award where it is satisfied that:

  • Its arbitration agreement or contract is otherwise caught by fraud or corruption.
  • That the arbitral award is such as is based upon an agreed contract.

Retrospective Application

This provision is even applicable to all arbitral proceedings invoked before or after October 23, 2015-much a retrospective amendment. It has raised the spectre of delays in the enforcement of the award due to possible misuse of the allegations of fraud while stopping arbitration proceedings.

Implication of Stay

While it secures immunity against fraudulent awards, it will also tend to:

  • Result in interminable delays in the settlement of disputes.
  • Increasingly invite higher judicial intervention contrary to the object of arbitration also as an alternative to litigation.

Extension in Qualifications of Arbitrators

The amendment blows wide open the qualifications of an arbitrator. The termination of Section 43J and removal of the Eighth Schedule amends:

  • Authorizing appointment of foreign arbitrators by parties in conformance with international standards in arbitration;
  • Permitting appointment of arbitrators having specialized knowledge in subject areas like engineering, science, or finance.

Influence on International Arbitration

With this modification, India has become a more favourable host for international arbitration. The amendment on multidisciplinary arbitrators adds robustness and efficiency to arbitration sessions.

Positive Impacts of the 2021 Amendment

This is a good amendment that attempts to modernize the arbitration framework in the country. The main ones include:

Pro-Arbitration

Stance The abrogation of such restrictive provisions, such as the Eighth Schedule, creates a conducive environment for India to become an arbitration-friendly jurisdiction.

Integration into Global Way

Greater Global Integration Introduction of foreign arbitrators will add to the strength in the international arbitration community regarding India. This is aligning India with countries such as Singapore and France, known for their arbitration-friendly environment.

Flexibility in Selecting Arbitrators

A Larger scope in terms of eligibility will allow parties to appoint professionals with the required expertise, thereby enhancing the quality of resolution of disputes.

Fraud Safeguards Automatic

stay on fraudulent awards will make arbitration fairer and more transparent and will improve stakeholder confidence.

Challenges and Criticism

However, critics have risen to give some negative aspects of the 2021 amendment as follows;

Rise in the turbocharging of Judges

The automatic stay provision under Section 36(3) may lead to:

  • Trends that slow down the execution of the awards, which is inapposite to the general goal of arbitration.
  • Applicants impose the court with many applications challenging the arbitral awards.

Undefined Terminologies

Some terms, for instance, fraud and regulations are general phrases. This lack of clarity raises several questions:

  • What is prima facie evidence of fraud all about?
  • To whom are decisions on factory floor regulations under Section 43J delegated?

Effect on Domestic Arbitral Lawyers

It may also preoccupy Indian practitioners with foreign personalities which may diminish the prospects for domestic arbitrators and possibly their effectiveness.

Risk of Misuse

As it is with fraud, some parties may invoke the provision to slow down the process of resolving the dispute and thus make the institution of arbitration inefficient.

Comparative Analysis: Past and Present Amendments

The evolution of India’s arbitration laws reflects the changing priorities of legislators and stakeholders. A comparison of key amendments highlights the progress made:

Aspect Pre-2015 Post-2015 Post-2021
Award Enforcement Automatic stay Conditional stay under Section 36 Automatic stay for fraud cases
Arbitrator Scope Limited to the Eighth Schedule Broader under Section 43J Global, multidisciplinary
Judicial Intervention High Reduced Increased under Section 36(3)

Importance of Arbitration in Corporate India

Arbitration is integral to corporate dispute resolution. With clear procedures and reduced litigation timelines, it complements mechanisms like types of meetings in company law to uphold corporate governance. Businesses increasingly prefer arbitration to maintain confidentiality and efficiency in resolving disputes.

Arbitration lawyers in arbitration scenario in Delhi.

  • Expert Handling: Dealing with stringent and complicated legal issues as provided under Section 36(3).
  • Strategic Advise: Optimizing outcomes in domestic as well as international arbitration.
  • Efficient Resolution: The management of cases to reduce delays.

More Information: Arbitration and Conciliation lawyer

Understanding Arbitration Through Corporate Law in India

Arbitration is closely intertwined with what is corporate law in India, particularly in addressing disputes related to:

  • Mergers and acquisitions.
  • Shareholder agreements.
  • Breaches of commercial contracts.

Therefore, it helps to achieve corporate solidity in an enterprise and produce confidence in investors.

conclusion

The Arbitration and Conciliation (Amendment) Act, 2021, relies on one of India's most difficult conditions for attempting to be a world centre of arbitration. Its focus on the synthesis of transparency and flexibility to the sphere corresponds to the new processes taking place in international dispute resolution. However, the effectiveness of the amendment will depend on the ability to sort out related issues such as reduction of the judicial intervention; elimination of the uncertainties; and fairness of the domestic arbitrators. More changes and integration placed India in well standing to step up to become more of a player in the international society of arbitrage.

Author Image

Advocate Priya Paul

Advocate Priya Paul, a proactive Delhi-based advocate, leads a skilled team. Her blog shares insights and updates on legal issues, helping readers navigate the law.

Frequently Asked Question

What is the primary objective of the Arbitration and Conciliation (Amendment) Act 2021? +
The amendment made in 2021 is to throw more light on the overall contemners and effectiveness of arbitration in India. It adds provisions such as an automatic stay on arbitration awards in case of fraud and corruption and relaxes the requirement for arbitrators in India to conform with international norms.
What changes were made to the qualifications of arbitrators in the 2021 amendment? +
The amendment also deletes the Eighth Schedule, which prohibited only persons from certain professions from becoming arbitrators. It now permits foreign/multidisciplinary professionals into arbitration and has successfully brought India into line with the global arbitration system.
In what manner does the Section 36 (3) automatic stay provision affect arbitration proceedings? +
The provision enables a court to assimilate an automatic stay on arbitral awards where there is an initial indication of fraud or corrupt practice. Even though it helped in the achievement of fair results, it will lead to the protraction of the implementation of awards, hence provoking judicial activism in arbitration issues.
What is the implication of the 2021 amendment to India’s potential as an international arbitration destination? +
The first is by recognising and allowing foreign arbitrators and the second one is by implementing international best practices through the said amendment…(table 2) This makes India a pro-arbitration nation. This puts India in a better place to woo international parties for arbitration of their commercial disputes.
What are the problems in that regulation that came into being in 2021? +
It includes: Increase in court involvement due to the automatic stay clause. Nonspecificity such as "fraud" and "regulations". Possibly overshadow domestic arbitrators by foreign professionals. It is important to address these issues to ensure that an amendment will see the light of success.

Need Legal Advice?

We are always available to guide the one in need with the right legal advice and build their confidence in the law.

Justice Should Always Be Accessible!

Contact Form

Priya Paul & Associates are looking forward to directing the way with lawful guidance. Reach us to find the best one with legal experts.

Contact Information